And bleh, body hair. That's a turn off for me. Small beards/scruffiness is totally fine, though.
Let me add to that list, Isaac Clarke:
Nice butt, nice face, nice voice. HE'S THE PERFECT MAN.
Also, Kurt Wagner/Nightcrawler, the only acceptable guy covered in hair/fur:


DAT ACCENT. Also, he's a trained acrobat. Take that as you will.













