Katta wrote:I'm not sure if that's what you meant by desire, but Ambrosia's face definitely reminds me of hentai images and to be honest not in a very good way (especially the worm out of her mouth...) The guys look nice though, I like the ones in the bottom more because they look fiercer, more war-like and make the image more intense.
Ahaha! Oh my goodness, does it give off that impression? What I meant was men's desire for her, the way that Helen of Troy was fought over or how Snow White was considered the fairest of them all. And does it look like a worm? It was meant to be a strand of hair. There's a lot of movement in war, so if you have long hair, it's bound to get caught in your mouth.
But I'm glad the guys are doing their job right! Thanks for letting me know what you think, Katta.
Mammon wrote:Things this promo doesn't really suggest: the intrigue. This is off course very difficult to display in a promo unless you get really on the nose about it, it's better to put that aspect in the description. However, I did expect something like a girl-fantasy story like Twilight from what I saw (not meant as an insult) rather than political intrigue, and your censored description doesn't dismiss that it might be such a Twilight-esk story (Still not meant as an insult).
About the other questions: I'm a man but I do prefer female-fronted fantasy as long as the protagonist is a strong character. I've said it before, the Protaggirl is the best trope if done well. (The moment I compare her to Bella from Twilight though, then it's meant as an insult
)
Oh, dear. If she makes anyone think of Bella, I have to say that I would feel rather ashamed as a writer! (No offense to anyone that likes her as a character. But let me just say that I'm not looking to create a protagonist like that.)
I would actually say this is far more
Dragon Age meets
Harvest Moon (as weird as a hybrid as that sounds), so if it's giving off
Twilight vibes (and apparently hentai ones?), I have got to change something.
Mammon wrote:Unfortunately I don't have a promo from my game to show, so I can't contribute to this thread with another addition to Judge.
Aww, that's too bad. I was looking forward to offering feedback on someone else's promo! But I see you have a game released in your sig -
Pervert&Yandere? I'm going to ahead and download it. I'm planning on joining a game jam soon, but after that, I'm playing your game and telling you what I think, if you'd care for feedback.
RedOwl wrote:Criticism out of the way (again - sorry for the negative first impression - but what use is it to not be honest?) - the theme I'm seeing here is definitely "young innocent person [of high standing?] (MC) getting caught up in a mess of war and hatred between the people around her." And - maybe suspicious looking blonde-haired guy is attempting to manipulate/control either her, or the situation in general? The black haired guy next to the main character definitely gives off the vibe of "good loyal bodyguard who will protect the MC at all costs" (although what is he holding? Looks almost like a spear, but he's holding it by the pointy end? Also confusing). The two at the bottom have really good expressions - and it seems like they are the aggressors - the ones stirring up whatever trouble is happening. The orange haired guy has a great look in his eyes - it's too bad most of his face is covered, haha.
The 3 words I would use to describe your promo: "dark power struggle." It gives me a feeling of drama, and maybe tragedy.
Hello, RedOwl! Don't worry about it - I need the honesty. Like I said in the opening post, it's your intentions that matter.
I was a little concerned that it was confusing. I was hoping that the blonde hair would draw people's eye first, and the direction of his gaze would pull the viewer's eyes to the guy in the lower right. And then, the direction of his gaze would make people look at the armored guy, whose glowing sword would pull you along to the orange-haired boy. And by following the spear, it would lead you to the dark-haired guy in the upper right, whose gaze would pull you to the protagonist in the center.
But I suppose that didn't work out so well! Though, it'd be nice if it serves as art full of symbolism that makes you ponder.
That said, I like the themes you've managed to pick up from it - dark power struggle is quite a nice description for it.
(And I clearly didn't make this obvious enough, but the orange-haired guy is throwing the spear at the dark-haired guy, who grabs it at the end to keep it from striking him fatally. Oh, and the blonde might seem like he doesn't have a left shoulder if you're seeing the white wing as being...well, a wing rather than something that's covering him. )
However, I can see I have my work cut out for me. It's time to take it back to the drawing board. Thanks, RedOwl!
Now, my first impressions of your first image is that it's sci-fi, and for whatever reason, it's giving me the feeling of an American animated series. The title and the computer in the background make think that virtual reality of some sort is involved. The use of the glowing device above is nice - it draws your attention down towards the cast. Since the purple-haired lady is in the center, I assume she's the main character, while the other two are people who will work together with her for whatever reason. I would also think they're potential love interests for her.
Based off her expression, she looks someone with a strong personality, sarcastic wit, and she may be a bit of a tomboy. The guy on the left makes me think of someone blunt, easily erring on the side of a jerk. He's wearing a suit, so he's probably as hard on others as he is on himself. The one on the right strikes me as being more aloof, and based off his clothes, he's probably casual and laid-back.
The 3 words I would use to describe it: Calm, cyberspace, and sci-fi.
And it's giving me a serene feeling because of the clouds.
I actually prefer the second image because there's more to see. Now, I'm thinking that the characters are entering a virtual world that, for whatever reason, gives me
The Land Before Time vibes. I'm also getting the feeling of exploration.
The 3 words I would use here are: Adventure, cyberspace, sci-fi.
Following along that train of thought, it gives me an adventurous feeling.
Now, let me see if I'm right. All right, I don't think I was too far off! Good job.
Also, feel free to share your placeholder promos or those that are a work in progress! This way, we can all help each other fix things before getting to the final version.