Starting Anime Club*

[Hanabira]

Hyouka, I started watching it recently and I like it xD It's school life, mystery, and comedy [?]

[Wootmuffin]

Hmm... here's some off the top of my head~

Supernatural/Suspense:
Ghost Hunt
xxxHolic (not what it sounds like)
Yu Yu Hakusho *very actiony rather than suspenseful

RomComs:
Fruits Basket
The Wallflower AKA Perfect Girl Revolution
Ouran Host Club
DNAngel

Action:
Full Metal Alchemist
Wolf's Rain
Knight Hunters
Samurai Champloo
Trigun
Cowboy Bebop

I've heard "GetBackers" is really good but haven't seen it and it doesn't seem to have a rating, but the plot sounds like it's a "comedy/action".