Hi,
I'm a programmer who is developing a custom engine that I plan to use to run my upcoming VN and/or dating sim projects.
I'm mostly new to VNs and the VN community.
Although I have my own vision of which features I would like to see implemented, I'm also curious what features/characteristics in my engine would allow me to attract artists to collaborate with me on creating games with this technology.
Are there any pain points that artists and creators in general face with current available platforms?
Would love to learn more about this subject.
Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
- Elsa Kisiel
- Regular
- Posts: 94
- Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2015 1:36 pm
- Completed: Shieldlock Holmes
- Projects: Home Spatial Home
- Contact:
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
Is that question aiming at game's programmer? Or at writer/visual artist/sound artist?
My portfolio : https://cara.app/elsakisiel/portfolio
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
Could be for anyone, but the focus is what makes an engine good or bad regarding visuals/graphics.
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
I think I understand what you're asking. Your engine should be able to accommodate multiple video formats (for example wmv, mp4, avi,ogg).
Some of my visual novels are at http://www.the-new-lagoon.com. They are NSFW
Poorly done hand-drawn art is still poorly done art. Be a Poser (or better yet, use DAZ Studio 3D) - dare to be different.
Poorly done hand-drawn art is still poorly done art. Be a Poser (or better yet, use DAZ Studio 3D) - dare to be different.
- puppetbomb
- Regular
- Posts: 123
- Joined: Fri May 19, 2017 4:04 pm
- Tumblr: puppetbomb
- itch: puppetbomb
- Location: USA
- Contact:
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
I don't think artists are motivated to work with someone based on the engine they use.
(Though I have refused to work with a client when they asked me to work in GIMP.)
(Though I have refused to work with a client when they asked me to work in GIMP.)
-
- Regular
- Posts: 39
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2018 4:11 pm
- Completed: ShSt - Bad Day
- Projects: ShSt - Afterparty, Collings University
- itch: https://gnve.itch.io
- Contact:
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
Idk if this is what you want to know but what drew me to the Renpy platform was that is was very easy to use and to create simple (or even moderately complex) visual novels. This includes that it is based on Python. I tried and failed quite a number of times to learn a programming language. Python is the first I'm able to stick to because it's tutorials are great. The language itself is easy read and write (no fluff I'd almost say it's wysiwyg) without giving up any power in what you can create.
Renpy is also quite feature complete so you can have the most basic novel with all features you'd want knocked out in an evening if you'd have to. As a noob in programming that is just awesome.
As a player I like Renpy because of easy controls, quick saving (RMB), skipping dialogue and the ability go back to an earlier point in the game with the scroll-wheel. Generally other oft-used (visual novel) engines lack one or more features. A game made for instance in RPG maker I'll generally skip because (i think) the controls are awful (for a VN or otherwise).
(But tbh I think a lot of Renpy games would be better if they railroaded the player a little more rather than trying to create an open world and ending up with a lifeless world and a player who can't progress without a walkthrough half the time.)
And Unity works well but it takes a lot of work (seen on WIPs I've tried) to get it up to a level where Renpy starts.
What I'm trying to say here is don't forget about the player if you want someone to play your VN as well.
Renpy is also quite feature complete so you can have the most basic novel with all features you'd want knocked out in an evening if you'd have to. As a noob in programming that is just awesome.
As a player I like Renpy because of easy controls, quick saving (RMB), skipping dialogue and the ability go back to an earlier point in the game with the scroll-wheel. Generally other oft-used (visual novel) engines lack one or more features. A game made for instance in RPG maker I'll generally skip because (i think) the controls are awful (for a VN or otherwise).
(But tbh I think a lot of Renpy games would be better if they railroaded the player a little more rather than trying to create an open world and ending up with a lifeless world and a player who can't progress without a walkthrough half the time.)
And Unity works well but it takes a lot of work (seen on WIPs I've tried) to get it up to a level where Renpy starts.
What I'm trying to say here is don't forget about the player if you want someone to play your VN as well.
-
- Regular
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2019 4:23 pm
- Projects: Helix Felix
- Location: PNW
- Contact:
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
I like renpy because there's a wealth of support and a wealth of cookbooks for mini games and making your game more complicated.
I like tyranobuilder/tyranoscript because it can handle live2D.
I started out with tyranobuilder because of it's "so easy a monkey could do it" layout. It let me dip my feet into game making when I was starting at zero. When I felt I had grown too big for it, I switched to renpy, because good support and cookbooks are something I value. Now I'm considering going back to tyranoscript (probably not tyranobuilder though because it's very slow to build in as a trade off for ease-of-understanding) because it can handle live2d, which is something I value.
So I guess the biggest thing to think about in a brand new engine would be: why would someone pick your engine? What does it bring to the table? File types? Ease of language? Speed? Built in mini game options? Export options? What makes it special?
I like tyranobuilder/tyranoscript because it can handle live2D.
I started out with tyranobuilder because of it's "so easy a monkey could do it" layout. It let me dip my feet into game making when I was starting at zero. When I felt I had grown too big for it, I switched to renpy, because good support and cookbooks are something I value. Now I'm considering going back to tyranoscript (probably not tyranobuilder though because it's very slow to build in as a trade off for ease-of-understanding) because it can handle live2d, which is something I value.
So I guess the biggest thing to think about in a brand new engine would be: why would someone pick your engine? What does it bring to the table? File types? Ease of language? Speed? Built in mini game options? Export options? What makes it special?
Re: Pain points of current VN engines? What makes an engine attractive to artists?
It just depends on how much you want to outsource. There are commercial companies that will do the engine and porting work for you.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users