#8
Post
by Seigetsu » Wed Jan 13, 2016 5:50 pm
Just finished playing this game yesterday. Thanks very much for sharing! (By the way, I also played "The Sad Story of Emmeline Burns" and really liked that as well)
So, with "Flower Garden", I really liked Chiaki's voice. The simple writing style also made it an easier read compared to some of your other works (with "Emmeline Burns", I found the narration a little droning at the beginning and it took me a while to get into the VN. With this one though, the narration came more naturally, especially given the characters' age). A lot of it was way over the top, but it was funny that way, which was another plus point for me personally. I think it gave Chiaki character. There were a number of little grammatical/spelling errors throughout the text (sorry, I didn't jot it down), which you might want to take a look at again if you were ever planning on revising this VN. Overall, though, these errors didn't interfere with the understanding of the story, so it wasn't much of a big deal either way.
The story really did remind me of "Sono Hanabira", but I actually liked this one more (because "Sono Hanabira" always felt very rushed to me...) I liked the buildup you've written and the involvement of Sawako, Tomoyo, and Aya in the storyline, but the end came rather abruptly, leaving me wondering "So what's going to happen to Chiaki? Will she get murdered by Chizuru's fan club? Or will she get murdered by a jealous Sawako?" I think it'd be nice if you could tie up some of those loose ends, maybe give the side characters clearer roles. Otherwise, just focus completely on Chiaki/Chizuru, and include less information on the side characters, because otherwise, we grow in love with the side characters, but they seemed completely forgotten at the end, which to me was quite disappointing.
Art-wise, I'm not a huge fan of 3D as it looks rather jarring on top of the photographic background. It took a while to get used to, but after a couple of scenes, it didn't bother me so much anymore. I did find the strands of Chiaki's hair that pointed out of the screen to look rather strange (like little horns). Some of the poses in the CGs were also a bit weird, like the scene with Chizuru feeding Chiaki with a strawberry, and she held the fork in a way that looked like she wanted to stab Chiaki with it. I'm not sure if it's intentional or not, but it looked quite out-of-place. Also, some of the backgrounds didn't seem to match the mood that was expressed in the text. For instance, the size of Chizuru's house - when Chiaki was supposedly awed by its size, her sprite almost filled the doorway, which made the house look very small, actually. The scene of them eating at the table also looked strange, as the sprites were superimposed onto the table without showing the table edge, so it looked like the table extended towards the viewer but the upper body of the sprites were just sitting there on top of the table (rather than the sprites standing by the table). Another thing was the choice of green for your textbox. It looked somewhat jarring to me considering the tone of the story. Maybe a soft pink or soft blue would be better? All of these are just little nitpicks - they're not a big deal, but I just thought I'd let you know.
Overall, I loved this VN. It was fun while it lasted, and Chiaki/Chizuru's interactions were really funny to read. Both characters developed beyond their cookie-cutter personality described in the beginning (especially Chizuru. I really enjoyed reading the sly side of her). Definitely inspired to draw some fanart, haha. I'll see if I have time to draw something this weekend. Once again, a huge thanks for making this! Looking forward to seeing more from you in the future.
Best of luck!